Sportsball StatsNewcastle United1–1Everton
Drawn
St. James' Park · Referee: T Harrington
- Newcastle United2–3Everton2025-26 · 1 Mar
- Everton1–4Newcastle United2025-26 · 30 Nov
- Newcastle United0–1Everton2024-25 · 26 May
- Everton0–0Newcastle United2024-25 · 6 Oct
- Everton3–0Newcastle United2023-24 · 8 Dec
- Everton1–4Newcastle United2022-23 · 28 Apr
- Newcastle United1–0Everton2022-23 · 20 Oct
- Everton1–0Newcastle United2021-22 · 18 Mar
- Newcastle United3–1Everton2021-22 · 9 Feb